Choosing the right suppliers is essential for ensuring smooth business operations, yet it is quite challenging. Luckily, there are a variety of tools designed to aid this process, such as supplier scorecards.
Throughout this guide, we will review everything regarding supplier scorecards, from their importance and benefits to key metrics to include in the scorecard for tracking. Thus, let’s dive into it.
What is a Supplier Scorecard?
A supplier scorecard is a strategic tool used across organizations to assess and track vendor performance based on predefined KPIs and metrics. It is an essential tool for continuously tracking and managing supplier performance and decision-making regarding further improvements.
The Importance of Supplier Scorecard
Before diving further into the article, let’s first understand the importance of the supplier scorecard and its main purpose.
The primary aim of using a supplier scorecard is to manage and monitor vendor performance. Scorecards are also essential for supplier evaluation and vendor relationship management.
Supplier scorecards provide insights contributing to effective communication, ensuring buyers and vendors work together to achieve the same goals.
When and How to Use Vendor Scorecards?
As far as we are clear on what supplier scorecards are and their importance, let’s understand when and how to use them.
For instance, you can use supplier scorecards when negotiating with the current vendors. The scorecard will show areas of improvement that suppliers should make to continue their collaboration. It helps to be more transparent and find collaboration edges.
Besides using scorecards to negotiate with the current vendors, such cards can be used to approve or disapprove a new vendor. During the approval process, when the procurement department considers whether or not to proceed with the collaboration, a scorecard will be useful to compare the performance of a potential vendor to current ones.
Finally, scorecards can be used to identify potential risks. For example, some suppliers may lack time management, resulting in slower lead times. Using scorecards will allow you to identify patterns and evaluate performance, mitigating risks associated with certain vendors.
Benefits of a Supplier Scorecard
Keeping a supplier scorecard will equip your procurement team with multiple benefits ranging from effective performance management to improved decision-making. So, let’s review the benefits in more detail.
Effective Performance Management
One of the main benefits of utilizing supplier scorecards is effective performance management. A supplier scorecard helps to streamline the processes of identifying high and low-quality performing suppliers with ease.
Also, scorecards aid the overall process of identifying poor performance areas. This allows businesses to collaborate with suppliers and take corrective action regarding the improvement of those areas.
For instance, the supplier might deliver goods of excellent quality but always tends to be late. In this case, the business is paying “opportunity cost” as the stock level management becomes less consistent, yet the stock is always of good quality. Not to lose the supplier but, simultaneously, ensure a smooth supply chain without late deliveries. Businesses can address this issue promptly. A person from your organization can gather data from the scorecards, contact the suppliers, and collaborate on a plan of action to improve performance.
Higher Levels of Objectivity
Another benefit of keeping supplier scorecards is that they help achieve a higher level of objectivity. By achieving higher objectivity and seeing a clear picture of supplier performance, organizations can mitigate risks associated with supply chain disruptions that could result from personal biases.
Enhanced Tracking and Transparency
When talking about the benefits, we cannot ignore the enhanced tracking capabilities and improved transparency levels that scorecards provide organizations.
With supplier scorecards, you can examine supplier performance patterns over time and gain useful insights for further decision-making.
Informed Decision Making
One more benefit of keeping supplier scorecards is informed decision-making opportunities. With supplier scorecards, you can track and evaluate supplier performance regularly, which allows you to identify suppliers that are more fit for further collaboration.
For instance, if you are working with more than one supplier to get delivery of the same raw material and overtime plan to terminate the contract with some of the vendors. In this scenario, the right solution will be to identify top-performing vendors and worst-performing vendors to understand which ones to keep and with whom the collaboration can be stopped. Supplier scorecards come in handy when identifying them.
Improved Collaboration Opportunities
Supplier scorecards also allow for improved communication and collaboration. Using a scorecard allows you to identify suppliers' strong and weak points, providing them with valuable feedback and collaborating on improvements together. These cards also help to set clear expectations and avoid potential misunderstandings.
Key Metrics to Include in Your Supplier Performance Scorecard
In order to enjoy all the benefits that keeping a supplier scorecard offers, you must be aware of the key performance metrics to track. These metrics include service quality, lead time, and compliance with the set regulations. Let’s review these in more detail.
Service Quality
One of the most important metrics to track is product and service quality. Quality of raw materials is essential as it directly impacts your end-product quality.
To determine the quality of the products delivered, you must first have predetermined contract specifications regarding the quality. For instance, the condition of the goods delivered, amount, and other quality parameters. In the longer run, you can also evaluate quality based on the rate of return and whether or not the product has achieved sales expectations.
Delivery/Lead Time
To make sure suppliers deliver the orders on time, you should track and analyze delivery timings over time. A good procurement software solution and a supplier scorecard will allow you to do so with ease and precision. One such solution is Tradogram, which comes in handy with all the necessary features to efficiently manage suppliers. The features range from supplier scorecards to real-time tracking tools, allowing access to comprehensive details regarding vendors and their performance.
Cost/Pricing Control
Although cost is not the main priority, it is still quite important. Thus, you can include cost and pricing KPIs in the scorecard for future comparison purposes.
When it comes to cost control, make sure the vendors deliver products within the budget and meet the contract's agreed-upon terms. Also, ensure that vendors contribute to cost savings and eliminate unnecessary expenses for your organization.
Compliance with the Set Regulations
Finally, do not forget to track the suppliers' compliance with the set regulations. Ensure that all the vendors comply with contract terms and conditions as well as overall policies regarding the safety and security of the materials.
How to Create a Supplier Scorecard?
Finally, it is time to dive into the practical section of this guide and explore strategies and steps on how to create a supplier scorecard.
#1 Gather Documents
Before proceeding with supplier scorecard creation, gather necessary guiding documents such as RFP documents, vendor’s RFP response, and contracts.
#2 Identify Key Performance Indicators
The next step is to identify key performance indicators that are vital for your organization. These, as discussed above in the article, include quality, lead time, pricing, and compliance. There are other metrics you can also include in the scorecard, such as sustainability and ethical practices.
After you have identified the KPIs, including the scorecard, make sure to assign weight to each of these. Determine the importance of each metric for your organization and establish clear priorities. For instance, timely delivery (lead time) is a top priority, while sustainability (for some) might not be in the top three.
#3 Develop a Scoring System
Afterward, make sure to develop an efficient scoring system that will help you gain comprehensive insights into vendor performance and compare the scorecard with other ones.
When everything is set, continuously collect data and assess suppliers. Based on the performance and scorecard results, you can choose top-performing suppliers for further collaboration and work with the ones that do not perform so well, aiming to improve performance (or terminate the contract if the performance doesn’t change over time).
Use Supplier Scorecards More Efficiently Than Ever with Tradogram
If you are looking for the perfect solution to track vendor performance and efficiently use supplier scorecards, then you are in the right place. Tradogram is a robust supplier management system that will help you to take care of every aspect of your procurement smoothly.
It comes in handy with a variety of useful features ranging from supplier scorecards and tracking features to real-time collaboration and automation tools.
To find out more about how Tradogram’s scorecards feature and others can help your organization thrive, schedule a free demo with our team. We’ll be more than happy to assist and answer your questions.
.png)
.png)
.webp)
